Golf-FAQ.com

when can you ask what club someone used in golf

by Lisandro Langosh Published 2 years ago Updated 2 years ago
image

Finally, it would not be breach of the rule to ask a player what club he had used on a previous hole. For example, during the play of the 5th hole, I could ask my opponent what club he used for a shot on the 3rd hole.

Giving advice
On the weekend, you may ask your friend what iron they just hit, or, while on the green, point to a spot and say, "I think this is the line." While such behavior is standard in a normal round, it's deemed illegal in competitive play. The penalty is two strokes.
May 26, 2016

Full Answer

How many rules do you need to know when playing golf?

If it's your first time entering in an event, from as comfortable as a club championship to U.S. Open qualifying, you need to be well-versed on golf's legislation. And because there are so many golf rules, one could feel overwhelmed. Fear not: Here are the 17 golf rules you definitely need to know when playing in a tournament:

Should you use a club from someone else’s bag?

—KYLE HOLMAN, VIA E-MAIL You might want to think twice before using a club from someone else's bag during a round. Rules Guy fears that no matter what his answer, it will drive a wedge between brothers … But all humor aside, this is the rare instance where ignorance of the Rules can actually be one’s salvation. His salvation, alas—not yours.

Can I share a golf club with my partner?

If your “partner” is indeed a partner in, say, four-ball match play, Rule 4-4b applies. It states that you two may share clubs, but the sum of your sticks can’t exceed 14. So unless he had only one club along with that shiny driver, you boys are in breach.

Do you have a rules question for the rules Guy?

Got a Rules question? Of course you do! Whatever it may be, send yours to [email protected] and the question may be answered in an upcoming issue of Golf Magazine. Until then, play by the Rules!

image

Is it a penalty to ask what club?

The Rules of Golf do not specify any type of penalty, but it is strongly frowned upon and you should just aim to make your own decisions with your club choices.

Is it a penalty to give advice in golf?

There is no penalty when an authorized party gives advice, but "the player should take action to stop this irregular procedure." He would incur a two-stroke penalty in stroke play if he allowed such advice to be given again.

Can a player ask for advice from another player about which club he or she should use for their next shot Rule 10.2 A?

caddie10.2a/2 – Player Must Try to Stop Ongoing Advice That Is Given Voluntarily. If a player gets advice. Continued) from someone other than his or her caddie. Continued) (such as a spectator) without asking for it, he or she gets no penalty.

Can you use someone else's club in golf?

with any club taken out of play. If a club taken out of play is another player's club, that other player may continue to use the club. Penalty for Breach of Rule 4.1c(1): Disqualification.

Can you ask someone what club they hit?

Giving advice On the weekend, you may ask your friend what iron they just hit, or, while on the green, point to a spot and say, "I think this is the line." While such behavior is standard in a normal round, it's deemed illegal in competitive play. The penalty is two strokes.

Can you ask for yardage in golf?

May I ask someone for a yardage? A. Yes. Matters of public information, such as yardages or the location of things on the course, are not advice (see Definition of Advice).

Are you allowed to scoop the ball in golf?

Rule 10.1a - The player must fairly strike at the ball with the head of the club such that there is only momentary contact between the club and the ball and must not push, scrape or scoop the ball.

What is Rule 10.1 A in golf?

New rule: Now players are granted much more leniency under Rule 10.1a which states, “If your club accidentally hits the ball more than once, there has been only one stroke and there is no penalty.”

Can you putt with the back of your putter?

Yes, Dave, it's allowed — provided you didn't push, scrape or scoop the ball with the head of whatever the club, per Rule 10.1a, lest you get the general penalty of two strokes in stroke play and loss of hole in match play.

Can you borrow a club in golf?

Golf facilities often provide rental clubs for a fee, if you do not have your own set. Many courses have rental sets of clubs available for golfers who do not bring their own.

What is an illegal swing in golf?

14-1. Players must strike at the ball with the clubhead rather than pushing it, scraping it or moving it with other non-striking actions. If the player's downswing is stopped or altered by an outside agency (e.g., a tree branch), the swing counts as a stroke.

Can you carry an orange whip in your golf bag?

Yes, it is legal to carry your Orange Whip in your golf bag. It does not count as a golf club and does not affect the fourteen-club rule. However, using the Orange Whip during a stipulated round other than for stretching is not permitted (e.g., swinging the device).

SAGolfLuvr

Good Day Golfers. I don't see a clear explanation on whether it is a penalty to ask a competitor in your group "What club did you hit?" during stroke play.

bkuehn1952

Good Day Golfers. I don't see a clear explanation on whether it is a penalty to ask a competitor in your group "What club did you hit?" during stroke play.

Rulesman

Any verbal comment or action (such as showing what club was just used to make a stroke) that is intended to influence a player in:

WarrenB

That’s why if you are Hitting second and your competition is looking at your clubs to get an idea you pull whatever club gets him in trouble. Either longer or short then after he hits go back to the bag. jack Nicholas and Arnold did this all the time

colin007

That's general knowledge. Not the same as the question asked in the OP.

SAGolfLuvr

Gentlemen Thanks for the discussion. So that rule has not been changed or relaxed. It always felt wrong to me and I always cringe when asked or if I hear someone asking someone else what club they just used. Thanks again.

Rulesman

Gentlemen Thanks for the discussion. So that rule has not been changed or relaxed. It always felt wrong to me and I always cringe when asked or if I hear someone asking someone else what club they just used. Thanks again.

What happens if you can't find your tee shot?

And if you can’t find your tee shot within the legal five-minute limit, you’ll incur a further penalty of stroke and distance. Oh, and you may want to consider laser surgery. I always play with 12 clubs.

What is the rule for borrowing in four ball match play?

Shakespeare was definitely onto something. Borrowing can get you in trouble. If your “partner” is indeed a partner in, say, four-ball match play, Rule 4-4b applies. It states that you two may share clubs, but the sum of your sticks can’t exceed 14.

What happens when you ask someone how they did in golf?

Sometimes when you ask someone how they did in golf, they may not have an answer right away. They may hesitate for different reasons. Some may just not be in the state of mind to answer you directly at the time.

Why do people ask how they did in golf?

If a club owner or another service provider asks how someone did in golf, it’s usually because they want to know whether the player is enjoying their experience. The way that a question is phrased can give more information that can help the person to improve their experience. This leads to greater profits for them.

What does it mean when a competitor breaks 100?

If your competitor is routinely breaking 100, it shows that they are a fairly disciplined player. Don’t respond to that news with signs of resentment. Be happy for them and ensure that you have something good to say in response to whatever they share with you.

Why is it important to ask a senior player how they think they did?

As a senior player, you want younger players to improve. Sometimes it is good to ask them how they think they did, to evaluate their own perceptions. You may also want to ask about a game if you weren’t there while they were playing. Asking questions provides you with information that you can use to further adjust your training to meet their needs ...

How to teach a child to play golf?

If your child has started to play golf, asking them about their game can be a way of demonstrating interest. You will want to ask about the game in different ways, as often as you can do so. Your child will be sensitive to the level of interest that you display. Pay attention to the cues that they give you, so that you can strike ...

How to help a golfer reflect on their game?

Being relaxed can help a player to reflect on their game and answer you with candor. Reflection does not come naturally to everyone. For some players, it’s a skill that they develop over the years. Asking how they did will help them in that process. As you journey with a player through the years, the way you ask them how they did in golf can ...

What is asking as a service provider?

Asking as a Service Provider. Service providers have a vested interest in ensuring that all of their clients are satisfied. If someone is always performing in a discouraging way on the golf course, they may not be as eager to keep playing, as an individual who has both good and bad days.

What is the USGA rule book?

The USGA rule book is the law for tournament play; it is absolute, without discussion. If it's your first time entering in an event, from as comfortable as a club championship to U.S. Open qualifying, you need to be well-versed on golf's legislation. And because there are so many golf rules, one could feel overwhelmed.

What happens if the ball falls off the tee?

Ball falls off tee. There's a shocking amount of players that aren't 100 percent sure what to do when this happens. Simple: You get to re-tee without penalty. (Exception: You've already whiffed on the first shot. If the ball then falls off, you have to play it as it lies.)

Do players understand they get help in such scenarios?

Most players understand they get help in such scenarios. In that same vein, most don't know the proper way to push ahead. You take your stance, from there getting one club length of relief. The new spot has to be without interference from what caused the drop.

Do you need a copy of the USGA rules book?

Most tournaments have rules officials on site, and all golfers should have a copy of the USGA rules book in their bag for more intricate situations and rulings . But the aforementioned points serve as the foundation for the obstacles you'll likely encounter during tournament play.

Can I ask for a yardage?

The distance between two objects is considered to be a matter of public information, not advice, and can therefore be exchanged without restriction. You can ask your mate how far it is from the tee to that ominous looking fairway bunker, for instance, or even how far it is from your ball to the green.

Can we tell each other what club we hit or intend to hit?

No. Sharing a yardage is fine, but once you get a discussion about what club to hit, you’re in the realm of advice. The penalty for breaching is two strokes, or loss of hole in match play.

Can my caddie show me where to hit my putt?

Your caddie or partner (in a pair’s match) can point out a line for putting, provided it is done before but not during your stroke. They must not touch the green in doing so, and cannot place a mark to indicate the line.

Can I watch someone putt if they have a similar line to me?

You can if it’s a fellow competitor, although crouching down behind their line as they make their putt to see how it breaks is considered poor etiquette, and if it annoys them, they are within their rights to ask you to stop. If it’s your partner/teammate making the putt, you must not position yourself in this way during their stroke.

image
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9